If you’ve been wondering about the key differences between STAHLS’ Inktra® Screen Printed Transfers vs Goof Proof® from our sister company, Transfer Express®, you’re not alone. Both are high-quality screen printed transfer options for apparel decorators, but each has unique features that make them better suited for different projects.
Let’s dive into the comparison to help you choose the right option for your needs. Here are the top differences between Inktra® and Goof Proof® Screen Printed Transfers:
- Carrier Type
- Price
- Application Settings
- Level of Detail
- Finish and Feel
- Print Size Options
- Ink Colors
Inktra® vs Goof Proof®: Key Differences
1. Carrier Type
One of the most significant differences between Inktra® and Goof Proof® is their carrier type. Inktra® uses a clear carrier, which is excellent for easy placement and works well with the Hotronix® ProPlace IQ™. On the other hand, Goof Proof® uses a paper carrier, which may require a bit more care but still provides great results.
2. Price
Goof Proof® is slightly more affordable due to its paper carrier, but both transfers are budget-friendly options. They come in the same single-image sizes—12.75”x9” or 9”x9” for single-color prints. While Inktra® is exclusively available for one-color designs, Goof Proof® offers multicolor options on gang sheets.
3. Application Settings
Inktra® is ideal for synthetic fabrics, thanks to its lower temperature application setting of 285°F. This is perfect when working with more heat-sensitive fabrics. Goof Proof® requires higher heat settings: 325°F for polyester and 365°F for cotton or blends.
4. Level of Detail
When it comes to fine details, Inktra® excels. Its clear carrier allows for precise ink placement, making it the better choice for intricate designs. If your artwork demands fine lines or complex patterns, Inktra® is your go-to.
5. Finish and Feel
Goof Proof® typically has a softer feel on the garment compared to Inktra®. However, depending on the specific ink color printing and the garment color, Inktra® is slightly more opaque and vibrant.
6. Print Size Options
Both Inktra® and Goof Proof® are available in two sizes for single-image orders: 12×12” and 12.75”x9”. Goof Proof® also provides more flexibility with Standard Gang sheets (11.25″x14”) and Jumbo Gang sheets (12.5″x17.5”), making it ideal for multicolor and larger designs.
7. Ink Colors
Inktra® offers 25 ink colors for single-color prints, making it a great option for simple designs. Goof Proof® provides a wider range of options, with 70 standard ink colors and Pantone matching available for custom shades. Goof Proof® also allows for multicolor designs when ordering a gang sheet.
How Are They Similar?
While Inktra® and Goof Proof® have some notable differences, they also share several similarities. Both transfers allow you to achieve a true screen-printed finish with plastisol ink that offers a soft hand feel on garments. The best part? All you need is a heat press to achieve professional results—no screen printing equipment required. This makes both Inktra® and Goof Proof® ideal for decorators looking to offer high-quality screen-printed apparel without the upfront investment in screen printing machines.
What’s the Difference Between STAHLS’ and Transfer Express®?
For those unfamiliar with Transfer Express®, you may wonder how it differs from STAHLS’. Both companies offer high-quality heat transfer products, but they cater to different needs. STAHLS’ focuses on a wide range of heat transfer materials like CAD-CUT® heat transfer vinyl and Emblems & Patches, perfect for special effect designs, flexible production options, or premium dimensional logos. Transfer Express® specializes in screen printed transfers like Goof Proof®, offering fast, high-volume solutions for simple or multicolor designs.
To learn more about the difference between these two brands, check out our detailed comparison here.
No matter which transfer type you choose, both Inktra® and Goof Proof® provide easy, cost-effective ways to produce high-quality screen-printed designs with just a heat press! Check out each below to find what’s best for your next project.